Empiriceme · Model · Theory / Model

Mises's Calculation Problem

Also called Economic calculation problem

Without market prices there is no way to compare the value of alternative uses of resources, so rational allocation becomes impossible in principle.

Mises's 1920 argument, distinct from Hayek's: this concerns valuation rather than information. Without prices for capital goods, there is no common unit in which to compare a steel mill against a railway.

In practice

  • A planner allocating steel between a railway and a hospital has no common unit in which to compare them, however good the data.
  • An internal transfer-pricing system that sets prices administratively finds no division can say whether a project is worth doing.
Standing
Distinct from Hayek's knowledge problem: this concerns valuation, Hayek's concerns information.
Subject
Economics & Incentives
Essay
The theories behind every argument about money

Search every entry·Every entry, A to Z