Empiriceme · Evidence · Bias / Effect

Politician's Syllogism

We must do something; this is something; therefore we must do this.

From Yes Minister, 1980s, and it entered serious policy commentary intact. Its diagnostic use is checking whether a proposal was chosen for its merits or for satisfying the demand to act.

In practice

  • A school responds to one incident by banning phones at lunch, because it is something, and the incident had nothing to do with phones.
  • A board facing a crisis approves the one intervention that was already drafted, because it satisfies the demand to act rather than the analysis.
Standing
A satirical coinage that entered serious policy commentary intact.
Further reading
Wikipedia
Subject
Law & Politics
Essay
What can be proved and measured about power

Search every entry·Every entry, A to Z