Empiriceme · Precept · Canon / Maxim

Quis Custodiet Ipsos Custodes

Also called Who watches the watchmen

Any body empowered to watch others must itself be watched, and the regress has no natural end.

Juvenal's line, and the pre-modern statement of the principal-agent and oversight problems. Its point is the regress: every watchdog needs a watchdog, and no institution escapes it by design alone.

In practice

  • A force that investigates its own complaints clears itself in most cases, and no individual finding is demonstrably wrong.
  • An audit committee that reports to the executive it audits has moved the problem rather than solved it, and the regress does not terminate by design alone.
Standing
The pre-modern statement of the principal-agent and oversight problems.
Further reading
Wikipedia
Subject
Law & Politics
Essay
Rules that restrain power, and advice on using it

Search every entry·Every entry, A to Z