Empiriceme · Precept · Normative Principle

Cromwell's Rule

Avoid assigning prior probability 0 or 1 unless logically certain.

Lindley named it for Cromwell's 1650 plea to consider that you may be mistaken. Formally, a prior of zero cannot be updated by any evidence whatever — certainty is unrevisable by construction.

In practice

  • An investigator who has ruled out one suspect entirely cannot revise, whatever the new evidence shows.
  • A forecaster who says a project has "zero chance" of slipping has left themselves nowhere to go when the first milestone moves.
Further reading
Wikipedia
Subject
Decision-making & Reasoning
Essay
Razors, rules and the tools of careful thought

Search every entry·Every entry, A to Z