Empiriceme · Evidence · Bias / Effect

Seinfeld Isn't Funny

A work so influential that its innovations became standard looks derivative to anyone encountering it after the imitators.

Cited by anyone encountering a hugely influential work after its imitators. It is a systematic distortion in how originality gets judged, and it affects the reputation of foundational work in every field.

In practice

  • A student reads the paper that founded a field and finds it says only what the textbook already said.
  • A management technique that was radical in 1985 reads as obvious now, and the person who reads it now concludes it was never insightful.
Standing
A systematic distortion in how originality is judged retrospectively.
Subject
Sociology & Culture
Essay
The measured patterns of social life

Search every entry·Every entry, A to Z